I Found the BEST Facebook Ads Strategy after ANDROMEDA Update (+43% ROAS)
By Antonio Ventre
Summary
## Key takeaways - **Classic Facebook Ads Strategy is Failing**: The traditional testing and scaling campaign structure for Facebook Ads may lead to a decrease in ROAS following the Andromeda algorithm update. [00:05] - **New Strategy Boosts ROAS by 23-41%**: A newly tested Facebook Ads strategy has been implemented, improving ROAS by 23% to 41% for e-commerce clients. [00:17], [00:22] - **Creatives Drive Targeting Post-Andromeda**: The Andromeda update shifts focus to creatives for targeting audiences, making traditional audience segments and lookalikes less crucial over time. [02:11], [02:21] - **Consolidate Ads, Minimize Ad Sets**: The optimal strategy involves decreasing the number of ad sets within a campaign and maximizing the number of diverse creatives (15-50) inside each ad set. [03:20], [03:44] - **Full-Funnel Targeting in One Campaign**: A single campaign with minimized ad sets can effectively target top, middle, and bottom-of-funnel audiences by leveraging creative diversification and broad targeting. [07:31], [10:43] - **Creative Diversity is Key for Algorithm**: To succeed with the new algorithm, creatives must be diverse in concept and angle, targeting different user awareness stages to avoid repetitive targeting. [02:31], [08:07]
Topics Covered
- Meta's Andromeda Algorithm: Your Old Ad Strategy Is Dead.
- Creatives, Not Audiences, Drive Meta's New Targeting.
- Fewer Adsets, More Creatives: The Optimal Meta Structure.
- Meta Auto-Optimizes Full-Funnel, If Creatives Are Right.
- Meta's Budget Allocation: New Audiences Still Dominate.
Full Transcript
If you're still running the classic
testing and scaling campaign after the
meta new Andromeda algorithm, bad news
for you, your rowas might go down soon
if most probably is not already down.
And we have tested a lot of different
strategies across all our e-commerce
clients so far and we found the best
strategy that is basically helping us to
improve our ROS by between 23 and 41%.
And in this video, I'm going to show you
guys exactly what is this strategy. So,
what is the new winning meta account
structure, which is basically based on
what Andromeda algorithm wants you to do
to maximize the performance. I'm going
to show you some test and differences,
some before and after in terms of rows
that we have generated with this new
strategy. I will also go through the
exact way that this new algorithm works
and why you should keep this into
consideration when you build the ad
structure and strategy overall for your
e-commerce brand right now. Okay, let's
jump on my screen. So, this is the
newest Facebook ad strategy uh that is
working post andromeda algorithm that we
use of course to uh help our clients to
scale with a very high return on the ad
spend. So, as you can see this is
literally just the before and after. Uh
this is the performance of this account.
uh on July before we applied the new uh
Andromeda strategy and this is was the
after. So as you can see the overall
return aspend increased by 23%. We went
from a 3.83
to 4.71. And on some campaign like this
one specifically we went from from a 430
return on ad spend to a 6.08 return on
the ad spend. And this one in red again
is the old ad strategy that is not
working anymore. And this one is the new
ad strategy that is working especially
well nowadays. So let me actually
explain what the new meta andromeda
algorithm is. So this new algorithm
basically is going to uh maximize the
target efficiency. So the way that you
target your audience uh towards content
and so what you basically need to do uh
the basically like the overall outcome
of this is that meta is now improving
the targeting and even more of your
targeting is done through creatives
right now. So audience and segments and
lookalike and all these things will
matter less less and less with time and
each of your single creative will target
different audiences. So what is the main
thing to prioritize here as you can see
is the create is the creative
diversification. Creative
diversification means how diverse are
your creatives and diverse I don't mean
changing the background or uh just a
simple thing like the color of the CTA
and they need to be actually diverse in
terms of angle concept and everything.
And this is basically how it works. You
see this is directly from meta guys. As
you can see, meta takes all your ad
creatives, reorganize them into
different buckets of audiences, and then
sub audiences, and then it will show the
related ads to the audience where this
ads is most relevant for. Here, this is
like a summary of how you should adapt
your strategy based on this new
algorithm. So, basically, you don't need
to split creatives by angular messages
anymore into separate adsets. So your
goal overall now is to decrease the
number of adsets inside your campaign
and maximize the number of ads inside
each single adset. So what is working
right now is basically not splitting
anymore the ad creatives by different
angles putting like six, seven, eight
different variations of ads inside one
adset and then test another angle in one
different adset. But now what you can do
is basically just put all the creators
inside one adset. You can be like 15,
20, 30, 40 different creatives, even 50
maximum creatives inside one adset and
increase the budget within that single
adset and create new adset when you have
reached the maximum capacity or when I
suggest to do it is basically when the
learning uh of the adset is maximized.
That means that it's not learning
limited anymore. So the the the adset is
performing well with a good return
aspect. In this case, you don't want to
touch the overall adset. And this is
when we basically need to create a new
adset with new creatives inside. As you
can see, what meta says itself uh is
that you can basically put different
angles and messages into the same
campaign or adset EDL advantage plus of
course and and let the system optimize.
So what is the uh what is the uh test
the results from the test that we got.
So as you can see this is the first one
and look here this is June uh 1st until
30th of June we got a 4.68 68 return on
the ads per on this account. And as you
can see, we had 1 2 3 4 5 6 seven
different ads. What we did, we basically
just increase the number of ads within
the same adset rather than splitting
into a new adset. And um and then the
rows, sorry, this is still July, so it's
June and July. Nothing happened. Same
number of of ads within the same adset.
And then we have increased the number of
ads to 11 from 7 to 11 uh in August and
the return ad spent went to 6.08
and uh what a lot of people were doing
right now is just like creating a new
adset and everything so it get optimized
again. But I think is that the the adset
already has a lot of uh data and so what
you can do when you put input new ads
within the same adset, you're going to
increase the number of um success rate
within that specific creative because
you're putting those creative inside an
adset that already has a lot of data
acquired. Now the thing is that uh the
ads the go like our goal to stabilize
the performance of the ad account is to
make sure that we have as many adset as
possible outside from the learning phase
and the learning phase itself happens
within the adset level. So if you're
splitting by different adset even if you
have a CBO it's going to be difficult
for each single adset to collect 50
let's say purchases within a week. And
so what you want to do, you want to make
sure that they are all stacked within
one single adset. And there is also
another example here, another different
account. And as you can see, uh this we
had three different creatives inside
this adset with a 4.24 return on the ad
spend in uh between June and July. So
two different months. And then what we
did, we had just added new creatives
inside. And as you can see, we went to a
550,
sorry 5.43
on the ad spend. And in total we had 13
creatives. So we add 10 new creatives
inside the same adset. Now uh when you
should do this and when you should not
do this. So as explained before you
should avoid doing this when you have
already an asset with 20 30 40 different
creatives inside and the adset is
already has already exited the learning
phase. You have another batch of 10 20
30 different creatives. Rather than
putting this creative inside an existing
adset, what you can do is just to use
another adset. Since you have 30 20
creatives, you can put all these
creatives inside the new adset. Um, and
the goal, your overall goal is to
minimize the number of adsets and to
maximize the number of ads within each
single adset. So, this is going to be
your goal. The campaign structure so
that is working right now as you can
probably understand is basically just
having one campaign. Uh and in this
campaign we have one or more adset
within a CBO setup. Um and uh the number
of adsets is basically minimized. So you
want to have as minimum adsets as
possible and maximize the number of
creatives. This is the campaign
structure and this is very important
because what you want to do here which
what you can read here we do not we do
not exclude
audiences. We do not exclude existing
customers. But in order for this to
work, you must you must create creatives
for different user awareness stages
because if you only create creatives for
the bottom of funnel uh awareness stage,
then your ads will keep targeting the
same people over and over again. So the
strategy only works if you do two
things. The first one is this one that
I've just mentioned. And the second
thing that you have to do is basically
make sure that you are uh putting all
your audiences here because what meta
does now basically meta targets
different people based also on um on
what you need like meta knows that you
want to grow the business in order to
grow the business. Meta knows that they
like you cannot spend just on existing
customers to give you the best spend. So
Meta nowadays, especially with your
Andromeda, they knows that you need to
have enough top ofunnel audience and
traffic that can sustain the middle and
bottom of funnel. And so what you need
to do is let Meta understand what this
middle and bottom funnel are in terms of
audiences. So Meta knows that it doesn't
have to push a lot of budget towards
this creative sorry towards these
audiences. So if you don't do this so
basically if you don't add your website
visitors to cart the checkout initiated
excluding the purchases into the engaged
audience as well as uh the clab your
list of uh you know all the contacts
excluding the existing uh customers into
the engaged audience uh meta is going to
basically probably push all your budget
over this audience because meta doesn't
know that this audience is an engaged
audience. So you must do it and then you
should do the same for existing
customers. In this case, what you want
to have is the pixel data purchases last
180 days and uh the email list in sync
with Cleio or any other tool you're
using. And you want to filter by all
customers. So a list of people in Cleio
that have made at least one purchase
from your website. So all your existing
customers basically make sure this is a
dynamic list and also this is a dynamic
list because if it's not a dynamic list
it's not going to be updated and uh it's
not going to keep you know the
performance. Um and then finally the
asset level actually very very broad no
custom exclusion and everything. Now a
lot of people might be saying oh um meta
is going to spend for sure the budget to
existing customers and everything but in
reality it's not true and uh I'm going
to explain with this example here below
but before going towards uh that example
here I want to you know just finalize
the um ad structure that you should use.
So all the other things right now
becomes optional because meta
automatically do the retargeting and the
retention within the prospecting CBO. So
the prospecting CBO doesn't even become
a prospecting CBO. It becomes a single
campaign like a fullfunnel CBO where
meta spend budget towards new customers,
engaged audience and existing customers.
Right? So you might need to use some
retargeting uh campaign or some
retention campaign if you run specific
brands just in specific cases. So uh
needs to be you know you just you kind
of need to understand the different
situation where and when you should use
it. Uh but what you want to do is just
keep it very simple. Manual targeting
for the retargeting uh manual campaign
uh website vistors Facebook engages
cleavio audience only inside exclude
existing customers because you are
retargeting only everyone that didn't
buy anything and uh broad placement one
adset 15 to 50 ads per adset and uh the
ideally you want to have one single
adset here as well and uh the retention
campaign manual targeting existing
customers only use P surplus clio data
broad placement one adset 15 to 50 ads
within the single ads. Why? Because
since these audience are very small, the
frequency will be very high. And so you
need to make sure that you have enough
content that keeps you know retargeting
the same people just to avoid the the
same audience see the same content over
and over again. Otherwise they will
start they will start reporting you and
if they reports you it's going to be a
huge problem because your CPM will go
very high and the only way to actually
see this is you basically need to have a
meta representative and speak directly
with them because they can only see it.
Another thing that you need to do is
when you have promo campaign. So let's
say you have like a Black Friday
campaign. Cool. So in this Black Friday
campaign, what you have to do, you still
need to keep your overall campaign set
up active. Um so one campaign CBO per
single product uh evergreen and then you
have an additional campaign where it's
going to be a broad setup similar to
this one. And then what you can have is
have a retargeting campaign website vis
engagement only if there is a specific
promo. like like in this case for Black
Friday uh you don't need to exclude
audiences in here and you don't need to
exclude audiences in here so we keep the
broad open the retargeting open and the
retention open as well I mean the
retargeting you still need to target
website visitors engagers and cleavio
audiences but you do not uh you don't
have to exclude any existing customers
as well as in the retention you don't
have to exclude existing customers why
because this one this campaign here so
you might be like Okay, but this
audience then is going to target the
same people uh that we're target here.
In reality, this is not going to happen.
Why? Because since you have this
campaign already here, then meta is
going to push the broad more towards um
new audiences compared to this one. And
this one is probably going to perform
very well for just like a couple of days
or maybe like towards the end of the
campaign. That's why usually this one we
launch it then we keep it active for
like 3, four, five days at the beginning
at the beginning of the campaign. and
the performance will drop and then we're
going to turn everything off and keep
only the broad active. U this is not
mandatory. I would extend the optional
even to the retargeting part because the
broad if you only keep the broad is is
also good because the broad will also be
able to um you know retarget the engaged
and retention. If you don't put these
two like the broad itself will push more
budget towards this especially during
the beginning of the campaign. Uh and
this actually good from one side. Why?
Because when you launch the campaign,
Meta will get a lot of data and we'll
see probably a lot of purchases coming
from existing audiences uh existing
customers or like all their targeting
audiences and so the optimization of
that specific campaign will be much
faster towards new audiences because
meta is going to leverage the data
collected kind of a lookalike concept.
So meta will leverage all the purchases
and analyze all the audiences uh like
all the behaviors and you know pattern
and everything of the audiences that
just bought your product. So probably
going to be retargeting audience and
existing customers and then it will
start pushing more towards new audience
that are similar to this and so the
targeting of the of the campaign will be
improved basically because the adset
already has a lot of data and um now
let's go to the concept of existing
customers. So here this is a screenshot
from our uh campaign right we don't
exclude anyone and this is what is
basically happening here so we spend 18k
in this account and as you can see 65%
of the budget went towards new audience
then
31% of the budget we went towards
engaged audience just want to remind you
that engaged audience is
still prospecting so is net new
customers at the end of the day because
these people, they never bought for
anything from you. And then you have the
existing customers and only 3.4% of the
total budget went towards uh the
existing customers. And as you can see
here, uh this is the return on ad spend.
So of course it's going to be higher for
the existing customers. It's going to be
uh the lowest for the new audience, but
overall it will be balanced. And this is
how we are basically doing a 4.56 return
on the ad spend because we want to
maximize for the return on ad spend
because even if you do some retargeting
campaign let's say email retargeting SMS
and everything you're probably not going
to reach all your existing customers and
so you still want to have some of your
campaign like to target your existing
customers especially if you sell
different products. So why meta here and
there's no spending uh on existing
customers and the answer is short
because we know what we're doing that
basically means that we create ads based
on different awareness level. So if you
don't do it you will mess up because
meta will start pushing towards existing
uh audiences like engaged audience and
existing customers a lot and everything
is not going to work. Now meta uh is
basically going to create a fullfunnel
uh targeting inside your single
campaign. So basically the al is
basically what I just mentioned before
that the algorithm knows exactly that it
must be a top of funnel to keep the
campaign profitable over time not just
today. Okay. And so it creates basically
a flywheel of content. You put all the
con inside and meta will allocate and
target different people on different
stages based on the messages that you
create within the ad creative strategy.
So the creative strategy becomes very
important because if you don't know how
to do it if you don't know how to create
messages for different audience segments
and for different user awareness stages
this probably is not going to work
right. So just make sure to follow this
up. uh and just make sure to shape and
use the proper messages and to create
creatives properly for different user
awareness stages. Otherwise, this is up
here. Probably it's not going to work
and you still need to exclude exist
existing customers. Of course on the
side what you can do you can also have
specific campaigns that push towards
prospecting fully called campaign
because maybe you want to have an
incremental reach there because probably
you're already spending a lot of money
on ads and so you want to have a
campaign that is basically going to
increment your reach new reach as much
as possible and so you probably need to
exclude a lot of different things like
engaged audience website vising existing
customers and everything because you
want super cold audience you want to
force it But again, most of the time
this is already working by itself on
Meta and we're seeing pretty much good
results even like 250 100k spent per
month US dollar. So this strategy is
what we're doing right now. These are
the results and this is basically it for
this video. If you like the video,
remember to leave a like, leave a
comment, subscribe to the channel, and
I'll see you in the next
Loading video analysis...